Thursday, June 08, 2023
Mar 30

Written by: Diana West
Saturday, March 30, 2013 8:42 AM 

My latest article for Dispatch International sets out to explain to Europeans how it could be that the mayor of Philadelphia is investigating whether the First Amendment covers free speech about  Philadelphia -- specifically, the Philadelphia Magazine cover story, "Being White in Philly."

It's not easy.


WASHINGTON, DC. In the summer of 2002, the Philadelphia Daily News published a cover story headlined, “Fugitives Among Us: Sometimes, Murder Suspects Hide in Plain Sight”. Forty-one mug shots of murder suspects illustrated the story, overflowing from the tabloid’s cover to the inside pages. The suspects were mainly black men, with a smattering of Hispanics and Asians. There were no white fugitives in the line-up.

Why? There were no white fugitives in Philadelphia at the time. This reality did nothing to ward off protests by activists who accused the newspaper of “racism” for publishing the facts. Soon, the newspaper issued an apology, and maybe Philadelphia civic life returned to normal – “normal” being a disproportionately high black crime rate and a low tolerance for disseminating or discussing evidence that reflects it.

This silent treatment held for the next decade. Philadelphia school officials, for example, insisted that frequent beatings and harassing of Asian students by black students at a majority-black South Philadelphia high school were “in no way racial”, Colin Flaherty, author of White Girl Bleed a Lot: The Return of Racial Violence, reports. Tensions climaxed on 3 December 2009, when black students attacked 30 Asian students, sending 13 to the emergency room. Flaherty writes that the US Justice Department later concluded that “a contingent of largely black school officials dismissed, ignored, and even encouraged attacks on Asian students”.

Similarly, the recent rise in America of “flash mobs”– large groups of mainly young black people who suddenly converge to commit acts of violence and mayhem in malls, urban centers, festivals and fairs – is often stripped of racial context by both media and political officials. The following comment by Michael Nutter, the black mayor of Philadelphia, scene of multiple flash mobs, is typical: “There is no racial component to stupid behavior”, he told the New York Times in 2010.

The following year, however, Nutter took to the pulpit of a Baptist church in part to castigate what he said was the “less than one percent” of black Philadelphia teens participating in flash mobs.

Addressing young, black rioters directly, Nutter preached a bright line of personal responsibility. “If you want us not to be afraid to walk down the same side of the street with you, if you want folks not to jump out of the elevator when you get on, if you want folks to stop following you around in stores when you’re out shopping … then stop acting like idiots and fools. … Just cut it out. And another thing. Take those doggone hoodies down, especially in the summer. Pull your pants up and buy a belt. … Learn some manners. … Extend your English vocabulary beyond the few curse words that you know. … And if you go to look for a job, don’t go blame it on the white folks, or anybody else. … They don’t hire you because you look like you’re crazy. That’s why they’re not hiring you.”

In light of such comments, it may seem strange to behold Nutter’s ringing denunciations of the March 2013 cover story of Philadelphia Magazine: “Being White In Philly: Whites, race, class, and the things that never get said.” Surpassing all precedent, the mayor has called on the Human Relations Commission, a government agency, to “rebuke” the magazine and the article’s author for committing “incitement to extreme reaction.” As UCLA law professor and leading First Amendment scholar Eugene Volokh told, the Democratic mayor is, in fact, advocating the “outright suppression” of speech he disagrees with.

The article in question is an anguished personal essay which links a series of interviews the author, Robert Huber, conducted with unnamed, white Philadelphians who live in the majority-black inner city. Huber’s goal was to add what he calls the missing dimension to the discussion of Philadelphia’s “vast and seemingly permanent black underclass” – the 31 percent of Philadelphia’s black residents below the poverty line.  “Our public discourse ignores the fact that race – particularly in a place like Philadelphia – is also an issue for white people,” Huber writes.

Mayor Nutter couldn’t more strenuously disagree. In effect, he is attempting to nullify the right of white Philadelphians to express their opinions about life in the inner city, thereby limiting the free press. Addressing the Human Relations Commission, Nutter said Philadelphia Magazine had “sunk to a new low” by running the article, and asked the commission for an opinion as to whether the article’s “prejudiced fact-challenged generalizations” qualify as “an incitement to extreme reaction”. Such legal language tracks a landmark US Supreme Court case, Brandenburg v. Ohio, which permitted a state to censor incitement to lawless action.

Given that the magazine article calls only for more discussion about race relations, the mayor’s reasoning seems legally off-kilter. Rue Landau, the commission’s executive director, however, has agreed to “take up the mayor’s charge”, stating: “The commissioners and I share the concerns of the mayor regarding the racial insensitivity and perpetuation of harmful stereotypes portrayed in the Philadelphia Magazine piece.”

This sends up red flags for First Amendment scholar Volokh. “The government is entitled to disagree with what people say, and to criticize them for what they say,” Volokh told “But here the mayor is not just calling for a response to the article – he is claiming that the article is unprotected by the First Amendment.”

Tom McGrath, the magazine’s self-described “center-left” editor, told Fox News he finds it “chilling” that the Philadelphia mayor “wants to use the government to censor a news outlet”. He added: “As a journalist – as someone who thinks free speech is really important – I find that really, really troubling.”

The commission will address the magazine article at its next meeting on 18 April.


Update: On March 27, Philadelphia's African-American Chamber of Commerce issued an ultimatum to Philadelphia Magazine: "Diversify" staff in 30 days, or else.

The magazine, the staff has been judged guilty of insufficient pigmentation, its opinions, professionalism, its very existence defective. What next, a show trial? It won't come to that, of course; it probably won't even come to a boycott.    

<June 2023>
June, 2023
May, 2023
April, 2023
March, 2023
February, 2023
January, 2023
December, 2022
November, 2022
October, 2022
September, 2022
August, 2022
July, 2022
June, 2022
May, 2022
April, 2022
March, 2022
February, 2022
January, 2022
December, 2021
November, 2021
October, 2021
September, 2021
August, 2021
July, 2021
June, 2021
May, 2021
April, 2021
March, 2021
February, 2021
January, 2021
December, 2020
November, 2020
October, 2020
September, 2020
August, 2020
July, 2020
June, 2020
May, 2020
April, 2020
March, 2020
February, 2020
January, 2020
December, 2019
November, 2019
October, 2019
September, 2019
August, 2019
July, 2019
June, 2019
May, 2019
April, 2019
March, 2019
February, 2019
January, 2019
December, 2018
November, 2018
October, 2018
September, 2018
August, 2018
July, 2018
June, 2018
May, 2018
April, 2018
March, 2018
February, 2018
January, 2018
December, 2017
November, 2017
October, 2017
September, 2017
August, 2017
July, 2017
June, 2017
May, 2017
April, 2017
March, 2017
February, 2017
January, 2017
December, 2016
November, 2016
October, 2016
September, 2016
August, 2016
July, 2016
June, 2016
May, 2016
April, 2016
March, 2016
February, 2016
January, 2016
December, 2015
November, 2015
October, 2015
September, 2015
August, 2015
July, 2015
June, 2015
May, 2015
April, 2015
March, 2015
February, 2015
January, 2015
December, 2014
November, 2014
October, 2014
September, 2014
August, 2014
July, 2014
June, 2014
May, 2014
April, 2014
March, 2014
February, 2014
January, 2014
December, 2013
November, 2013
October, 2013
September, 2013
August, 2013
July, 2013
June, 2013
May, 2013
April, 2013
March, 2013
February, 2013
January, 2013
December, 2012
November, 2012
October, 2012
September, 2012
August, 2012
July, 2012
June, 2012
May, 2012
April, 2012
March, 2012
February, 2012
January, 2012
December, 2011
November, 2011
October, 2011
September, 2011
August, 2011
July, 2011
June, 2011
May, 2011
April, 2011
March, 2011
February, 2011
January, 2011
December, 2010
November, 2010
October, 2010
September, 2010
August, 2010
July, 2010
June, 2010
May, 2010
April, 2010
March, 2010
February, 2010
January, 2010
December, 2009
November, 2009
October, 2009
September, 2009
August, 2009
July, 2009
June, 2009
May, 2009
April, 2009
March, 2009
February, 2009
January, 2009
December, 2008
November, 2008
October, 2008
September, 2008
August, 2008
July, 2008
June, 2008
May, 2008
April, 2008
March, 2008
February, 2008
January, 2008
December, 2007
November, 2007
October, 2007
September, 2007
August, 2007
Privacy Statement  |  Terms Of Use
Copyright 2012 by Diana West